It goes without saying that any Pixar film is going to have a certain amount of buzz surrounding it. Their latest film Luca is perhaps getting the most discussion because it is not getting a theatrical release but going straight to Disney Plus. Some have seen this as a sign of a lack of faith by the studio in the project while others have deemed it a compliment as it is being singled out to market the streaming service, which is so key to their current business strategy. I guess it depends whether you see Disney Plus as more of a dumping ground or shining platform which side you land on.
Anyway, beyond its release let’s talk about the movie itself. What’s interesting is a lot of the feedback I am hearing I do not agree with. I know I’m in the minority but Soul wasn’t a favorite of mine. I still recommended it (and certainly don’t hate it) but the script became muddled and the message felt all over the place- particularly when it comes to the mid-section involving a cat. At one point it seemed to be saying to embrace your spark, find out what you are meant to do in life but in other ways it said that spark alienated you from other people and led to unhappiness: that a normal life is better than a creatively inspired one.
So Soul is a movie I admire for the music and animation but the script let me down. Now Luca, on the other hand, has much smaller ideas and it in my opinion does a better job in executing that simple vision. To put it simply Luca is a story about friendship, summer and growing up. That’s it. No big emotional punches or big action scenes. Just a simple sweet story.
To be more specific Luca tells the story of a young fish creature named Luca (Jacob Tremblay) who bristles up against his controlling parents and wonders what can be in the world above the ocean (obviously a plotline I love. The Little Mermaid die hard fan!). One day he meets a boy named Alberto (Jack Dylan Grazer), and he realizes they become human when dry on land and turn back into fish creatures when wet.
Both Alberto and Luca’s dream of racing around Italy on Vespas and when they meet a girl named Gulia (Emma Berman) they enter a race to win their own vespa. There’s a ‘villain’ Ercole who challenges them in the race and plays the part of the bully needed for this kind of narrative. The bigger threat is any of them getting wet from the ocean or even worse rain!
I can see why some think the story of Luca is too simple but I don’t agree. I liked being with Luca, Alberto and Giulia as they ate gelato and raced around the Italian countryside together. And it’s not like there aren’t deeper themes which can be pulled from the story. Obviously the idea of hiding who you are and being fearful of being discovered is something that will ring true for LGTBQ audiences and more.
But mostly it’s a story about friendship and I’m a huge sucker for those kinds of stories. There’s something special about the friendships we make as children. The free spirited nature and lack of agenda give a purity to the relationships that is tough to impossible to replicate as adults. Luca captures this magic, and I really enjoyed it.
And hey it made me want to go to Italy so nothing wrong with that!
Fortunately if you have Disney Plus you don’t have to decide whether to watch Luca or Soul. You can enjoy both to your hearts desire. Someday I hope to see both in a theater but for now I’m grateful for the artists at Pixar and their incredible track record of touching films.
Luca is a delightful tale of summer friendship the whole family will love
8 out of 10
6 thoughts on “Pixar 45: ‘LUCA’ or Some Fun in the Pixar Sun”
I was fairly disappointed by Luca. It was fine, but it didn’t feel like anything all that great to me. It all felt like things we’d seen before and it didn’t do anything special. Ultimately it just feels very forgettable.
On the other hand I absolutely loved Soul. And maybe that is more of an “adult” Pixar movie and this is a “kids” Pixar movie. Which is fine – balance is good!
I know the message of Soul takes some time to think about but for me at least it’s super powerful. I definitely don’t think it’s saying that your spark alienates you from other people and leads to unhappiness (only that in extreme cases that CAN happen). Rather that your spark isn’t the end all be all of life. You can absolutely love music, it can be your passion, but at the end of the day if that’s all you care about it might not be enough if it causes you to shut other people out of your life or rush by all of the other things the world has to offer. For example, Joe never took the time to really get to know his barber because ALL he talked about was music. I liked the idea that we don’t need to have some great purpose – instead joy can be found in all of the little moments of life and wonders of the world. And we have a spark, or sparks, that bring us joy. As someone who has been struggling with feeling like I’m never good enough, doing enough, achieving enough, this really resonated for me.
Thanks for sharing your take and interpretation. I can see how you could have that take
I haven’t seen Luca yet, but since I’m like you and wasn’t blown away with Soul, I’m hoping the smaller story of Luca will please me more.
Do you have Disney Plus?
Yes, I do. I just haven’t gotten around to watching it yet, lol!
I was kinda meh with Soul. I will make the effort to check out Luca. 🙂 Thanks!