Treasure of the Sierra Madre Review

treasure of sierra3Tonight I didn’t have much going on so I figured why not check out the special screening of The Treasure of the Sierra Madre on the big screen. I knew almost nothing about this film except that it starred Humphrey Bogart and is a classic but I figured that’s good enough for me! (With the moviepass I could basically see it for free so why not?).  I didn’t know what to expect and came out of it really impressed. I can see why it is a classic and in many ways it reminded me of the current Oscar favorite The Revenant, except it was clearly its superior in every way.  I find it fascinating to compare the two.

Released in 1948 Treasure is written and directed by the great John Huston starring Humphrey Bogart (Dobbs) , Walter Huston (Howard) and Tim Holt (Curtin).   They play 3 men who decide to prospect in Mexico for Gold in the 1920s.

treasure of sierra5They start out with the best of intentions- promising to be moral, upright and to not let the money go to their heads.  Dobbs in many ways starts off the most confident in his own morality while Curtin is more morally consistent.  Howard, on the other hand, is morally practical, even to the point of understanding why a man might kill him for the money.  He says something like ‘I don’t think I’d do it, but I’d sure be tempted’.

What’s really brilliant is the morality of the film is set up with Dobbs and Curtin getting taken advantage of by a shifty businessman in Tampico before they go prospecting.  This is somewhat of a prediction of the conflict to come.

treasure of sierra9The cinematography by 3 time academy award winner Ted D McCord is fantastic, using shadows to show the physical and moral challenges facing the men.  Watching it makes me yearn for black and white movies again! I’d take it any day over the bleak, albeit impressive cinematography in The Revenant.

Treasure 7 Bandito Treasure 2 DobbsThe three leads are so good with particularly Bogart’s Dobbs unwinding  in such a believable way.  It doesn’t happen over night. In fact, at one point he is rescued by Curtin and we think that may create some kind of obligation between the two men.  Instead, Dobbs becomes more and more suspicious of Curtin’s motives and more guarded over his money.

There is a great scene where Curtin tries to stop a poisonous lizard from going in Dobbs hiding place for his ‘share of the goods’.  Dobbs accuses Curtin of stealing from him and Curtin says ‘don’t believe me! Put your hand under the rock’. He’s challenging him to test his trustworthiness and see if the lizard will pounce on him.  The sequence works brilliantly and tells you so much about both characters.

Howard, as the practical moral compass,  never once gives a big speech but consistently warns them about the curse of the gold.   It was impressive how Dobbs becomes dirtier and more disheveled as the greed overtakes him.  In some ways his story arc kind of reminded me of Lord and Lady MacBeth as their lust for power, causes moral compromises that lead to mental instability.   It’s like I could see Dobbs trying to wipe the blood from his hands!

Treasure 6 GoldFaceThe dialogue is so well done by Huston.  It felt authentic to the characters and settings for the 3 leads the entire time.  I never felt like someone was ‘acting’ or trying to win an Oscar.  These were prospectors and I bought how they talked and the evolution of the characters.  Each man spoke in a distinct way that fit who they were and who they become.  It is also believable how Dobbs goes from begging for 2 pesos at the start of the film to a scene where 25,000 in gold is not enough.

treasure of sierra7Where the Revenant gets a lot of its character from the cold surroundings, Treasure of the Sierra Madre gets a similar effect from the heat.  You can always feel the heat of the Mexico sun on the prospectors.  It feels every bit as taxing as the scenes in Revenant, particularly towards the end.

treasure of sierra8One of the problems I had with The Revenant (which I don’t hate btw) was its bleakness and almost complete lack of humanity . It becomes kind of deadening by the end and something that should be shocking feels a little ‘meh’.  There’s just a limit to how many times you can be stunned by an actor freezing to death. It becomes kind of lifeless film-making by the end.

Treasure in contrast has many moments of humanity, even humor, which makes the eventual moral crisis and madness all the more compelling.  We care about these men because we’ve seen both their goodness and darkness.

The performances are also a lot more subtle and absorbing than in The Revenant.  This is partly due to the script but also the acting is just that good.

treasure of sierra4The only flaws I saw in the film is the complete caricatures of the various Mexican groups.  There’s the ‘Indian Mexicans’ who treat Howard as a medicine man after he saves a little boy and then the Bandits who are literally too stupid to recognize giant bags of gold. That seemed a little hard to believe.

The music also sometimes seemed a little too cute for the story but it wasn’t a big problem.

treasure of sierra2Small flaws aside, Treasure of the Sierra Madre is a must see for any movie fan.  John Huston directed and wrote a true masterpiece and the acting is some of the best I’ve seen.  It is an absorbing story with a compelling moral conflict that I think I will purchase on blu-ray.   I particularly suggest if you have seen The Revenant watch this and see if you notice the similarities like I did.  What do you like best?

Have you seen Treasure of the Sierra Madre?  What did you think?  I’m honestly kind of shocked with how much I liked this film.  It was so well done.

I give it an A+

11 thoughts on “Treasure of the Sierra Madre Review

  1. I saw this for the first time a few months ago and it is indeed a classic! You can’t really go wrong with Humphrey Bogart!

    It just goes to show how people can be idealistically for/against something, but when temptation comes, no matter how strong we are, we havta be careful lest we fall into it.

    I didn’t have a problem with the medicine man scene. And I dunno, if I saw pure gold that still wasn’t refined and had come straight from the ground, I dunno if I would recognize it as gold myself.

    1. Glad you enjoyed it too. I was really surprised how much I liked it. I was expecting something good but not something so morally complex.

  2. Absolute A+. Bogie is my favorite and this is in his top 5-10 without a doubt. He is fabulous but I loved the supporting work as well. Soooo good.

      1. It’d be interesting to do some posts on not obvious movie dopplegangers. Like not a remake or sequel but just similar or inspired by

  3. Hello Rachel, I don’t know if you are still looking for comments, but after watching “Asphalt Jungle” two nights ago, I decided to look for and watch “The Treasure of the Sierra Madre” for the first time since I was about12 years old in New York. As a teenage, I loved the books by the mysterious German socialist B. Traven who wrote the original novel, and wanted to see what the movie looked like today as a veteran social-democrat living in Israel all my adult life. It really is a magnificent cinematic achievement. Along with Bogart’s brilliant performance, I was particularly impressed by how John Huston directed his father Walter, and assumed that he was worthy of an Oscar for best-supporting actor, which I see he got. It was only after reading the reviews that I discovered that the tall white-suited American who Bogart/Dobbs asks for a handout a few times at the beginning was the director John Huston himself. In my mind, the film stands the test of time as one of the great achievements of Hollywood. One of the reviewers wrote that every human being should see this film, and I agree. Huston kept going, and I also think his last film, “The Dead”, based on the final story in the great James Joyce short story collection, “The Dubliners”, is very quietly powerful. Maybe that will be next on my list to revisit, along with “The Misfits”. If you haven’t seen it, worth checking out. In the age of Covid-19, we are now in the middle of our 3rd severe lock-down here in Israel, there is plenty of time to watch good cinema on my computer.

    1. Thank you so much for your wonderful comment. Just got a super mean comment so it was so nice to read your insightful and lovely comment. I agree about Treasure of the Sierra Madre. It’s a movie that has really stayed with me since seeing it years ago. I want to see Huston’s other films. Thanks for the reminder

Leave a Reply to Hillel Schenker Cancel reply