- Jim Carrey as:
- Ebenezer Scrooge
- Ghost of Christmas Past
- Ghost of Christmas Present
- Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come
- Gary Oldman as:
- Bob Cratchit
- Jacob Marley
- Tiny Tim
- Tim’s voice is provided by Ryan Ochoa.
- Colin Firth as Fred
- Bob Hoskins as:
- Mr. Fezziwig
- Old Joe
- Robin Wright Penn as:
- Fan Scrooge
- Cary Elwes as:
- Dick Wilkins.
- Mad Fiddler
- Businessman #1
- Guest #2
- Portly Gentleman #1
I already mentioned in my ‘Family Movies I Like that Others Do Not’ post that the Disney 2009 version of a Christmas Carol I really enjoy even though many others do not. Hopefully here I can explain a little bit more thoroughly why it works for me even if it is not perfect.
The biggest difference is this is the only stop motion animated version so it has the feel of an animated film with the realism of live action. For what is basically a ghost story I think it works very well.
I think shots like this are beautiful
I love the scenes where we are flying through London although some go on a bit too long (As I have said I have a weakness for characters flying in movies. I almost always love it) .The colors are bright and the way it uses shadows and light is very beautiful.
Another big difference is this version tries to stay extremely close to the text. There are passages such as the men joyfully shoveling snow off the rooftops that is almost never included but it is here.
I also love in that same scene when they are flying past a steeple and cross we hear ‘hark the herald angels sing’ and Scrooge (in a direct quote from the book) justifies his lack of faith in Christ by asking the spirit about poor people on the sabbath day. (the same man who suggested workhouses and prisons is condemning the church for being closed on sabbath day! See he’s rationalized his lack of need for faith and Christ’s grace. It reminds me of how the Pharisee’s question Christ in the Bible)
““You would deprive them of their means of dining every seventh day, often the only day on which they can be said to dine at all,” said Scrooge. “Wouldn’t you?”
I have never seen a version that includes this but it is crucial to understanding the message I believe Dickens meant behind the story that not just shutting out Christmas, but rationalizing away Christ made Scrooge cold.
The Spirit says in response
““There are some upon this earth of yours,” returned the Spirit, “who lay claim to know us, and who do their deeds of passion, pride, ill-will, hatred, envy, bigotry, and selfishness in our name, who are as strange to us and all our kith and kin, as if they had never lived. Remember that, and charge their doings on themselves, not us.”
That is such an important moment in the story and almost never included.
Anyway, other differences is that 6 actors portray most of the characters Jim Carrey ( who plays Scrooge remarkably straight), Gary Oldman, Colin Firth, Bob Hoskins, Robin Wright Penn and Cary Elwes. All are very good in their differing roles.
Another difference is it sticks close to the book in its portrayal of Scrooge. I went back and read the novella before starting the project and there is absolutely no attempt by Dickens to soften Scrooge or make him sarcastic. I don’t mind when versions do this but it is not canon. Listen to how Dickens describes Scrooge:
” Scrooge! a squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous, old sinner! Hard and sharp as flint, from which no steel had ever struck out generous fire; secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster. The cold within him froze his old features, nipped his pointed nose, shrivelled his cheek, stiffened his gait; made his eyes red, his thin lips blue; and spoke out shrewdly in his grating voice. A frosty rime was on his head, and on his eyebrows, and his wiry chin. He carried his own low temperature always about with him; he iced his office in the dog-days; and didn’t thaw it one degree at Christmas.”
I mean the rooms get colder when he enters. He is a “squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous old sinner” (again making the religious fall a part of his bitterness and anger). I actually think this version captures that Scrooge extremely well.
It is perhaps a more enjoyable movie when we think of it as telling a ghost story and less of a Christmas story. They include Marley’s jaw coming off and ignorance and want is dark and quite scary.
Strengths- As I said the closeness to the book is a real strength. I also like the performances and I know some hate the stop motion look but I think it is beautiful. The music by Alan Silvestri is wonderful including the closing credits song by Andrea Boceli- God Bless Us Everyone.
I wish more people had seen it because I would have loved to see what Zemeckis could have done with other classic stories like Jane Eyre using this medium.
There are many moments which the film gets right that few do.
I love that it is Tiny Tim’s declaration of Christ that first moves Scrooge. Nothing else has but as soon as he hears Bob talk of Tim he worries and begins to feel again.
“Somehow he gets thoughtful, sitting by himself so much, and thinks the strangest things you ever heard. He told me, coming home, that he hoped the people saw him in the church, because he was a cripple, and it might be pleasant to them to remember upon Christmas Day, who made lame beggars walk, and blind men see.”
A lot of versions skip over this line trying to appeal to those of all faith but it is a loss in my opinion because can a nice pleasant holiday really be enough to get someone to change? No it is a higher religious conversion, a higher meaning to life and goodness, that prompts Scrooge to repent his ways.
I also like the way the appearance of all 3 spirits is very close to the descriptions in the book. This and the Muppets I believe come closest to the ethereal quality of Past. He looks like a candle, which is creative.
The ending is good when Scrooge see’s his body on the bed and is desperate for some sense of feeling at this death. Then we see the couple who is grateful the death gives them more time to pay back their loan (something often skipped) and then the Cratchit’s mourning the loss of Tim.
Weaknesses- Trying no doubt to appease modern viewers they do spend a bit too long in segments zipping through London. Particularly at the end when they are chased by black horses carrying a hearse it goes on too long and gets old. I typically fast forward that segment.
Also I don’t see why for the pawn shop scene Scrooge needs to be shrunken down with a high pitched voice. Another ploy I suppose to appease modern viewers.
It can be pretty dark and scary for kids so it will depend on your child’s tolerance for those kinds of films. The scene where Present dies is like no other version. It is very scary but I think it is cool. Like I said if you look at it as a ghost story (which it is) like Corpse Bride or something like that than it is less upsetting. But it is the area where the movie takes chances. It embraces Christmas Carol as the ‘scary ghost stories and tales of the glory of Christmases long, long ago’.
And I know for some who aren’t as in love with the book as I am the strict adherence may be a problem. They want a more nuanced, softer Scrooge than the book gives us. It quotes a lot from the text and makes no attempt like in Muppets or other versions to explain things in a modern way.
So all in all, I know it isn’t perfect but I really like it. It’s a definite part of my holiday viewing and I appreciate all the hard work which went into making it accurate, heart felt and visually captivating. Others do not care for it but that’s their opinion and this is mine. 🙂
12 thoughts on “Scrooge 6: Disney’s A Christmas Carol”
It’s a decent adaptation at most.
RIP Bob Hoskins!
RIP Bob Hoskins for sure. I’m glad you reminded me of his fairly recent passing.
I liked this even better this watch through but I realize I’m in a minority on that one. I’m glad you see it as decent. It definitely is. I’d still give it a solid B. We all have those films we respond to that others dont. I know it isnt perfect but I like it. 🙂
So many beloved celebrities died this year; it’s sad 🙁 .
It’s too flashy…the moments when they are actually focus on the characters, they can be good (especially Cratchit is done very, very well, perhaps the best performance ever, but sadly wasted in this movie). Some of the effects (especially when the floor just vanishes) are very impressive. But what is, for example, the point of the giant chase scene at the end? It drags, and has nothing to do with the story.
Add to this the usual “uncanny valley” motion capture often creates, plus, it seems like they didn’t do the scenes with all actors together…they never really look each other in the eyes, which results in the “dead eye” effect which really kills some of the scenes (obviously other film maker learned from it and opted to let the actors act together instead of going for the gimmick of having one actor playing different roles).
I think it angers me because it could have been good if they had put the story first and added the special effects only where it makes sense, but they put the special effects first, which drowned out the story. So in a sense it is not the worst adaptation out there, but it might be the most frustrating one, because so much potential got wasted…and in a way, this offends me the most. Not the B-Movie which might be bad, but in which everyone gave his very best, but high budget movie which tries to distract the audience with special effects.
Yeah the chase scene goes on too long but other than that I didnt have the same problems you did. I actually thought they made eye contact fine. The special effects weren’t a barrier for me or frustrating. I agree the zooming through city is too long but easy for me to ignore. It didnt drown out the story for me. Different tastes I guess
One nice thing is those flashy sequences are all in the same spots so easy to fast forward over which is what I do when I normally watch. I feel like they put in that stuff to appease people less interested in the story but they shouldn’t have.
Still lots of choices were right on. I love when Crachit is crying right in Scrooge’s face. I don’t see how the special effect sequences waste the good sequences. They are entirely separate in my mind. It’s kind of like I didn’t care for the narrative device in Book of Life but I can separate that out from the strong sections.
Like I said i love that the sabbath day section is included and almost never is. I like when the versions remember this is a religious conversion not just a christmas conversion.
But the flashy segments move it from an A to a B but dont discount the whole film for me, but just my opinion.
They pull me out of the narrative, so they are a Problem for me.
That’s too bad. I didn’t find them that distracting just too long