We made it through the package films! Now we are ready to start the glorious era of 1950’s Disney. Aside from the 1990s that brought us 9 Disney animated films the 50’s gave us 5 and they are all good:
1. Cinderella (1950)
2. Alice in Wonderland (1951)
3. Peter Pan (1953)
4. Lady and the Tramp (1955)
5. Sleeping Beauty (1959)
Glorious! And it all started with Cinderella. In fact, we should all be grateful for Cinderella because without its success we may have not seen any more Disney films because at the time of it’s release Disney was 4 million dollars in debt. Cinderella cost 3 million so if it had flopped they would probably have gone bankrupt.
While the package films had kept them in the game, they had not had a serious hit since Snow White in 1937 (or perhaps Dumbo) but it had been a while. It had also been over a decade since they had been allowed in the European market and their overly ambitious films of the early 40s had not made money.
So naturally they went back to their money-maker, classic fairy tale princess stories, and it served them quite well.
Cinderella is the centuries old fairy tale about the girl in ashes who through good fortunes becomes a princess. It has been told in nearly every culture going all the way back to the middle ages. Some tellings are ghastly and morbid. Others are fanciful and fun. For whatever the reason the story has remained consistently popular in nearly every era of the written word. It’s really quite remarkable when you think about it.
I already reviewed the Disney Cinderella and 3 other versions on my youtube channel.
To watch all of the reviews go to http://youtu.be/XQGdwKoeqfc?list=PL7wz447AgL4yacznPUN2r_A6WdEXPtuxj
Just the Disney review is here
In that review I defend Cinderella from the feminists who feel she is only a pretty face. I talk about the hard work and good friend she is.
So this time I want to talk about other things that I noticed more this time around.
Disney had long wanted to do a version of Cinderella. In fact,in 1922 he made a short about a cat Cinderella but the story is basically the same.
I think Disney’s affection for the story going back to his early days shows in the movie. Even the villains are fully fleshed out characters with decent amount of screen time. It feels like well thought out and lovingly crafted movie.
One thing I noticed in this go-around is aside from the intro it takes 22 minutes before we see or hear from Lady Tremaine and the girls. These early minutes are all spent in helping us to get to know Cinderella.
We see her wake up from dreaming, sing about her dream (with one of the best princess singing voices by Ilene Woods), rescue Gus from the trap, and then get breakfast ready.
This is much better than the introduction of Snow White who we mainly know is beautiful, wishes on a well and meets the Prince and is banished. You haven’t gotten to see her work or interact with friends like we see Cinderella.
Her opening song is one of my favorite in all of Disney.
I also love the Sing Sweet Nightangale sequence. The animation in the bubbles is beautiful.
This human side is key in helping us feel bonded to Cinderella. She’s a good person. She deserves to be happy. Unlike say Ariel who is pretty young and selfish, Cinderella only thinks of herself in dreams, which makes you want her to achieve them even more.
A lot of people hate the mice in Cinderella because of their high pitched voices. I suppose I wouldn’t want to buy albums of their singing but for the part of itty bitty mice I think it kind of works.
Here’s an interesting video where they have changed the mice voices to what their natural register would be like. I don’t mind it but I kind of think the mice are cuter in the original. What do you think?
The mice are such sweet friends to Cinderella. (It is kind of funny that the mice and birds have clothing but not the cat or dog. Don’t any of the other characters think it is funny all these dressed critters around the house?..). When they make Cinderella her dress it is such a happy, loving gesture.
With such love and excitement put into it, it really is quite a devastating moment when it gets destroyed. It is perhaps the lowest a character gets in any Disney film and we have spent so much time with her it affects us as audience members.
But of course she is rescued and by a woman no less (funny how the feminists never mention that). The Prince doesn’t rescue Cinderella. She rescues herself because as the Fairy Godmother says ‘if you lost all your faith than I wouldn’t be here and yet here I am”.
The Fairy Godmother is voiced by frequent Disney contributor Verna Felton, and I think it is one of the great vocal performances in Disney history. It is warm, funny, sweet and of course magical!
And a great song!
The songs are all great written by a group called the Tin Pan Alley and attributed to Mark David, Jerry Livingston and Al Hoffman who all won Oscars.
Bibbidy-bobbity-boo won Oscar for best song. I feel like songs like that never win any more? It’s always to the tender ballad? I guess there was that Eminem song a while back so maybe not. Bibbidy was so popular it had 4 top 5 cover versions by Perry Como, another by the Fontane Sisters and others.
While we are learning about Cinderella we also get to know the King and Arch Duke in some very funny scenes. And while the Prince never speaks more than a few words we actually learn a lot about him through these scenes.
We learn the Prince wants to marry for love and has been reticent to pick any of his father’s choices. We learn he is bored by most of the women he meets and his father thinks he has his head in the clouds (like Cinderella). We also learn his father desperately wants Grandchildren! (Enough to destroy his house ranting about it!)
At one point the king is told the Prince has promised whomever fits the shoe he will marry. The King says he will punish (maybe even kill) the Arch Duke if someone, any woman, isn’t found to fit the shoe, even if it is not the woman the Prince is in love with. ‘He’s given his word and we’ll hold him too it!’. Now that’s a man who wants to be a Grandpa!
So of course Cinderella is off to the castle and dances with the Prince in admittedly the weakest song and sequence of the film. But Disney at this point had used the ‘instant love’ trope so many times in shorts and features it is certainly no surprise to see them use it again. In fairness, at least in this story there is a limited time period where they could fall in love so at least it makes sense. I mean at midnight she is back to rags and the chance is over.
Next we get the search for the owner of the slipper. The Arch Duke comes and Lady Tremaine shows her most evil side locking Cinderella in the attic.
Lady Tremaine is one of the best Disney villains of all time. Her whole life seems to be devoted to helping her daughters and to lording her power over Cinderella. I don’t know of many horror movie villains that get quite the glee out of ruining a single person’s life. In the world of Disney she is without a doubt one of the greats. I kind of wish she had a good villain song but it works.
The wicked stepsisters, Anastasia and Drizella, are practically as evil as their mother and I remember seeing them as a child and asking my Mother why their dresses looked so strange? To think those huge bustles were a fashionable look (in Pecos Bill a bustle gets turned into a trampoline!)
Lucifer is another great character that actually takes up a lot more of the movie than I remember. What a horrible cat!
I’m reminded of the quote from Babe:
“There are many perfectly nice cats in the world, but every barrel has its bad apples, and it is well to heed the old adage, “Beware the bad cat bearing a grudge.”
Aside from shorts it had been since Pinocchio that Disney had animated human characters and there is a fluidity to their movement which is pleasant to watch. This is perhaps because 90% of the human interactions were actually filmed in live action and then copied by the animators. It was basically the motion capture of it’s day!
The backdrops are also back to form with Cinderella. We get some beautiful works of art for the characters to act around.
The final segment of the film when Cinderella is locked in the attic are really quite desperate. Gus and Jaq must get the key all the way up the daunting flight of stairs!
Of course we all know the end of the story. Cinderella and the Prince get married and she is rescued from her hard life.
I certainly hope we have not become so cynical as a society that we can longer tolerate the joy of a happy ending to a fairy tale. It is not like Cinderella gets by easily. In fact, aside from the Fairy Godmother, her life has been incredibly difficult. If anyone deserves a happy ending it is her.
Well, I’m not cynical. I believe in happy endings for all of us. If we are like Cinderella and are a good friend and work hard than we will all find happiness in life. We may not find great love and be a princess but we can all get our happy endings. That’s why Cinderella’s story has endured for so long.
I also believe in rescuers. The Fairy Godmother rescues Cinderella at her lowest moment. I know in my life I have had similar moments of rescue when a good friend has insisted I take their love and be helped out of a miserable situation. No magic per say but the results were equally profound.
Regardless, Cinderella has great music, lovely animation, a terrific villain (several actually), and a heroine that displays many laudable traits for our children to emulate. It absolutely deserves to be one Disney’s classics and I love it.
Overall Grade- A+
Also, Cinderella is one of the few movies that Disney actually produced pretty good sequels to in their sequel phase of the 90s. Particularly Cinderella 3 where Lady Tremaine goes back in time to try and undo all the good that happens to Cinderella.
27 thoughts on “Movie 12: Cinderella”
This movie is a masterpiece and I love Cinderella as a person. She’s an incredible hard worker and has such a big heart. She’s one of those girls whom you don’t think twice about marrying.
It really is just about perfect. And such a lovely example of friendship.
It’s a good movie, but it looses some points with me on the grounds that it’s somewhat two movies in one…one about Cinderella, one about the mice. The art is stunning, though. Nothing beats Mary Blair.
I’d say both of those are done very well but I see your point. Mary Blair is awesome
I actually really like So This Is Love, and while I think the rest of the soundtrack (besides the songs) is not so remarkable, Cinderella is in tradition with all the Disney greats by having great music. You pointed out the backgrounds of Cinderella, and I think this was one of the highlights of the visuals since the backgrounds are very stylized, exaggerating certain features of buildings, bridges, landscapes, etc. I thought it worked well to give it the feel of an illustrative fairytale book and made the film feel like it was re-accounting the story from Cinderella’s point of view, who I could see romanticizing the story. Good review.
I agree about the backgrounds and I guess maybe I was a little tough on So This is Love. It’s a fine romantic balad. I love Nightangale and Bibbity Bobbity Boo and Dream is a Wish.
She’s just such a likable heroine. Right up there with Belle for my favorite. She works hard, is compassionate and a good friend- 3 very important traits
Wow, you put this film up there with say Little Mermaid, Big Hero 6, Tangled, & Frozen, eh? Wow, I’m definitely going to try to give this a rewatch soon and see if I like it as much as you do.
Yep. Beautiful artistry, great songs, classic story, humor and real heart. When Cinderella sings Nightangale with the bubbles it’s stunning and when she gets the dress torn to shreds it’s devastating. Perhaps they could have developed the Prince a little more but only real qualm. And a fantastic villain
Agreed most likely! Oh, did you know that the actress who played the stepmother was he same one who aged Maleficent in Sleeping Beauty?
I didnt know that. Cool.
Yes, that is awesome!
By the way, the Lawn Gnome has posted his review for Cinderella. Hope you enjoy!
Well, it was and then got deleted. Oh well! 🙁
Never mind, the review for Cinderella is back on. Hope you definitely enjoy! Feel free to let me know what you think!
Like in ‘Sleeping Beauty’ I too think that the more cynical arguments made against Cinderella have gotten a bit out of hand. While Aurora really doesn’t have much to her character and is made up for by making Maleficent and the Fairies so engaging and entertaining, Cinderella actually does have a good characterization. What she doesn’t lacks in proactivity for her own interest she makes up in the virtue of faith she represents. She could have sunken into self-pity, hate and loathing like so many people, but instead, kept her kindness and faith to deserve happiness, similar to Snow White. In every scene we see of her in the house, she’s working her socks off and helping out the mice wherever she can. We may praise proactive heroines to no end but so many of them have this incredibly annoying self-loathing or self-pitying side, and I’m really starting to hate that. There doesn’t seem to be room for role-model characters like Cinderella in our society, and I don’t really like that.
The scenes with the mice and Lucifer always struck me as Disney’s own take on the Tom & Jerry cartoons, which while fun I still think they kinda slowed the plot down a bit. I wouldn’t take the out, but I still found them occasionally out of place. And is it just me or does Jaq’s normal voice sound a lot like Danny DeVito?? 😛
With all that said, I very rarely watched Cinderella as a child. But looking at it today I respect it a whole lot more for being a monumental part of the Disney animated canon and immortalizing the fairy-tale for decades to come. And hey, what gives hope to so many people across the world cannot possibly be a bad thing as far as I’m concerned. While I don’t think it’s necessarily the Disney film for me, I certainly respect it and the impact it’s had on Western culture and hope it continues to be loved by millions.
All great points. I agree. I’ve reviewed all of the Cinderella versions on my youtube channel and there is just something about the story that appeals to me. It’s a hopeful story and I agree Cinderella works hard never gives up. A lot of people think it is the Prince who rescues her but that isn’t true. She rescues herself because the Fairy Godmother says ‘if you didn’t have faith I wouldn’t be here’. It is her faith and love that brought her rescue. I love that.
This Disney version has great songs, terrific villain and it looks gorgeous. I think the backdrops and animation in general are underrated. I love the Sing Sweet Nightingale number even though it doesn’t really have much to do with the story. It’s just so pretty.
Did you get a chance to see the most recent version? Check out my review of it. I really enjoyed it! Thanks for reading and adding such thoughtful comments.
I didn’t actually get the chance to see the recent film, in large part due to my own skepticism and because I was too heavily involved with university work to find the time. While I’m still sad that Sleeping Beauty got the shaft in terms of adaptation quality, I’m glad to hear that you consider the new Cinderella a worthy adaptation. 🙂
Yep. I was skeptical too but I loved it! I think with Cinderella it has been done so many times that I suppose I’m more open to different versions but it stays pretty close to original animated version.
Here are all my Cinderella reviews if you are interested. Cinderella: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7wz447AgL4yacznPUN2r_A6WdEXPtuxj
Amazing how a story like Cinderella can remain popular so long and be told in different ways.
Just watching Cinderella 2. Strange Magic is a masterpiece
Ha! It does give a bit of perspective when you see the truly awful films
Check out this Disney theory I made about two characters from some of your favorite Disney movies. And comment on there what you think.
I understand the feminism viewpoint, but Cinderella is so much more than their cynical arguments. It is a great Disney tale and, as you said, one that has survived a long time.
I agree 100% 🙂