It’s the moment you all have been waiting for. I have finished reviewing the Pixar movies so that means it is time for me to rank them in order of less great to greatest. I was hesitant to review the Pixar movies at the beginning because I love them all that I didn’t know if they would be good reading but I hope you guys have enjoyed my efforts.
Ranking is tough because honestly I have my #1 and then about a 8 car pile-up for 2nd place. They are all so different and appeal to me in different ways.
That said, here goes!
15. Brave– I enjoy it but doesn’t deliver the movie it promises in the strong introduction.
14. Cars 2– Both Cars movies are pretty close for me. I like the energy in 2 and think the spy elements are creative.
13. Cars– A little slower than I remembered this time around. Still a nice message about Main Street USA and lovely animation.
12. A Bug’s Life– A sweet little movie with a predictable story but I like the characters and it is well written.
11. Monsters University– I love the message of Mike finding out his true calling is not his dream. It makes Mike into one of Pixar’s most complex character.
10. Monsters Inc- A delightful film with great chemistry between Sulley and Mike. Creative world building with Monstropolis.
9. Toy Story 2– A fun action adventure comedy for Woody, Buzz and the gang. We get real heart with Jesse and her song. Plus Woody must decide what he wants out of his life.
8. Toy Story 3- Pixar’s take on a prison escape movie is full of drama and keeps you on the edge of your seat. Humor from Barbie and Ken and a pitch perfect ending.
7. Ratatouille- A movie that makes me smile from beginning to end. I love Remy and his desire to cook French food. It is funny, sweet and lovely. Paris never looked better.
6. Finding Nemo- Great adventure as we follow 2 storylines with Marlin looking for Nemo and Nemo in the aquarium. Nearly every joke works and a real heart to boot.
5. Wall-e– Starts out as a silent film following the life of a little robot left on earth. Then we move to space and Wall-e and Eve help the humans realize their potential and get back to where they belong. A movie that grows stronger each time I watch it. Emotional, sweet, beautiful and bold.
4. Incredibles– The best superhero movie. A great film about marriage and work. Funny, exciting with a terrific villain. Looks great and a total delight.
3. Inside Out– I’ve seen it 3 times in theaters and every time I am more blown away. Emotional, funny, layered adventure for both the emotions and Riley. Bing Bong was an unexpected character and the ending is perfect
2. Toy Story– When I watched for this series I was amazed at how it held up. It’s really a story about how Woody learns to overcome his weaknesses- his jealousy, his fear. We all fear of being forgotten and that is Woody’s fear. It still looks good for the story and the emotion and humor hold up. In the end it is the Pixar I have loved longest so that counts for something.
1. Up– No surprise there. You guys know it is my favorite movie. The opening is emotional. The journey of Carl to overcome his grief and make his devotion to his wife is touching, funny and lovely. I love the animation and music. It is just perfect.
Here we go to one of the more controversial Pixar entries. A lot of people hate this movie. A lot more people hate the sequel but we’ll get to that later. I do not hate them. They aren’t masterpieces but they aren’t total trash either.
Before I start the review I will give the same caveat I gave in my Planes: Fire and Rescue review- these movies are nutty. I recently talked about turning your brain off in a movie. Well, this is a movie where I kind of have to turn off my brain. Why? Well, let me give you an example of the kind of questions this world brings up. So we have a world of all cars, no humans. There are girl cars, boy cars, old cars, new cars. How do cars procreate? Are there baby cars that grow and morph into regular cars or do they emerge full size from some kind of car tree?
Wouldn’t a world of all cars be really polluted and would they really care? They are cars. Their blood is basically gasoline- the grossest, dirtiest product out there. Also, who decides when they want to discontinue a car? Isn’t that kind of cruel? There is a Model T in the movie so obviously some cars are repaired and others are left to die with no new parts (in Planes: Fire and Rescue they have discontinued his gear box. I guess his number has been determined by someone to be up…very odd).
You get the idea. If you start pulling at a string on this movie you will be down the rabbit hole in seconds. It’s bizarre. Who thinks of a world made entirely of cars?
Well, John Lasseter loves cars and he directed this movie. And if you can see him through all the nuttiness there are some things to enjoy in Cars.
To begin with there is a young rookie car named Lightning McQueen who is cocky, brash and rude. All the voicework is great in Cars including Owen Wilson as Lightning. The opening race scene for the piston cup is so much fun. It reminds me of going past the Indy 500 track every day on my mission. They capture the feel of the races and I think the way they added the eyes and mouths work for the characters. Compare them to the mouths and eyes for Thomas the Tank Engine and you will see what I mean.
Lightning feels he is too good for his sponsor Rusteze who make bumper ointment which again in this nutty world is a funny joke. I also LOVE so much that my favorite radio guys from Car Talk Tom and Ray are featured as the Rusteze spokespcars. This is especially moving as Tom passed away last year and I miss hearing his voice every Saturday on my radio. I hate cars and I loved Car Talk. There are a ton of cameos in Cars including racing greats like Mario Andretti. As someone who lived near the Indy track that was a lot of fun.
Lightning McQueen ends up getting lost on the way to California and ends up in historic Route 66. This is the strongest part of Cars- the love letter to Americana, Main Street USA and Route 66. It makes you want to get in a car and take a drive down an old highway and eat at an old diner. It’s a part of America that has been forgotten and that is the true message of Cars. To not forget the America that made us great.Anyway, he runs into a town called Radiator Springs and ends up damaging the road. In order to be released the Judge orders he fix the road which will take a few days. Meanwhile nobody at the track knows where he is or has a way to reach him. (We also learn earlier that Lightning has no real friends but an agent who could care less). So Lightning is forced to spend time with the yokels of Radiator Springs.
There is Sally the Porsche voiced by Bonnie Hunt. (Like I said all the voice work is great)
Paul Newman is Doc Hudson- a crochety old Hudson car. George Carlin is a hippie VW camper van, and Tony Shalhoub from Monk (the man of every accent) is one of a set of Italians who dream of changing tires of a Ferrari.
Cars has a huge cast so I could go on and on but the true co-star of the movie along with Lightning is Mater, the tow truck, voiced by Larry the Cable Guy.
I know some people hate Larry and hate Mater but I think he is sweet, loveable and innocent. I really enjoy the character. He’s so eager to please others and make friends. That’s very loveable. He even says his signature ‘get r done’ that Larry used to do on tour. So I like Mater. And I really like the friendship Lightning and Mater form. It’s kind of a more simpleton version of Woody and Buzz.
The plot to Cars is nothing we haven’t seen before. Of course Lightning grows to love the cars of Radiator Springs and of course he is humbled and becomes a better person. That is all fine. Where the movie is great is like I said in the homage and spirit of old time America and Route 66. I love this segment when Sally and Lightning are driving on their date. It’s so beautiful.
I also love this scene where Sally tells Lightning about what happened to Radiator Springs. It’s the story of so many American towns and a great message for kids to learn about. They need to know about the death of Main Street America and how things used to be.
Another special thing about Cars is how it uses music. This is one of the few Disney movies I can think of that uses a soundtrack (Lilo and Stitch?) instead of an original score/songs. I think this was because they wanted to pay homage to so many of the great songs about Route 66. They are all lovely songs. I’ve always found Rascal Flats Life is a Highway especially engaging. If this song doesn’t make you want to tap your toes I don’t know what will!
There’s also a lovely numbers by Brad Paisley, James Taylor, Chuck Berry, Sheryl Crow, John Mayer and more. I love the soundtrack!
As far as weaknesses there are problems. As I’ve already said there’s the ridiculous world-building and the predictable rather saccharin story. Also I must admit this watch-through I was surprised how long it is. At nearly 2 hours I did find it wearing out its welcome. I was bored for stretches where we get long segments with Doc, Lightning and Mater racing, repairing roads, talking and other scenes. There is one bizarre scene where Lightning and Mater go cow-tipping with tractor cows (such a strange movie!). This movie could easily have 30 minutes taken away and not suffer a bit. In fact, it would be greatly improved.
But all that aside I do love the message of Americana and remembering our rich history of small towns, Main Street, and Route 66. There are towns in America that the Interstate has made us forget but they were special places and we should remember them. Even the most flourishing of small towns are full of empty abandoned storefronts. I say this as someone who lives firmly in suburbia it is a real loss. I loved all of that. It also looks beautiful with vistas of red rock and sunsets. I also liked the friendships built by Lightning, Mater, Sally, and others. It’s a nice message for kids and the ending is very sweet.
Plus, I find Larry the Cable Guy funny so Mater is great comic relief.
It’s a mixed bag for me Cars and I didn’t like it quite as much this watch-through as I have in the past. But in the end these movies were made to entertain little boys without as much concern for crossover appeal as other Pixar movies. And I have yet to meet a little boy that doesn’t love Cars. Nothing wrong with that.
I will be seeing Big Hero 6 in the next 3 hours! Oh boy!
I was talking with a friend about Robin Hood and told her despite its problems it is one of the most rewatchable Disney’s. What I mean by that is some movies are masterpieces but more weighty than the kind of thing I want to watch over and over again .
So what are those movies that I don’t mind repeat and frequent rewatching? What’s the one that if I’m feeling like a movie that will entertain but not challenge me what do I pick? I will add that I seem to have a unique high tolerance for repetition. Other people tire of music, movies, food, books and I just don’t. If it is something I like than I like it forever and repeatedly.
That said, some films like The Lion King I love but the intensity makes it tough to rewatch again and again.
I will also say that all of the Pixar movies with the exception of Brave (yes even Cars 2) are very rewatchable. That’s why I’ve struggled to write up reviews of Pixar ,movies . How many ways can I say masterpiece?
Here goes in no particular order:
1. Tangled- romantic comedies are probably my favorite genre to rewatch. Tangled is funny, light, joyous, beautiful and a terrific villain.
2. Robin Hood- Maybe not the most ambitious Disney film but the humor makes it very rewatchable. I love the voice performances and while it is a bit too long it is so much fun I enjoy rewatching it.
3. Jungle Book- I hate the ending but other than that it is charming, funny, and the music is the true star. It clips along so well with moments of real heart. It is certainly up there in the movies I’ve seen the most.
4. Emperor’s New Groove- Again not the most ambitious but so full of laughs that it is great to rewatch. Comedies are often the best for rewatching as we don’t always feel up to an intense emotional experience.
5. Aladdin- Another comedy makes the list but Aladdin is so much fun with the manic energy of Robin Williams. Every time I see it I spot a new impression or moment I had missed before. It will entertain both boys and girls equally and it is just one I wouldn’t mind watching on most any day.
6. Frozen- I can see many of you roll your eyes because you are sick of this movie. I repeat I don’t get sick of movies. If I like them I like them and I like Frozen. I could listen to the music all day and the humor is great, pacing a lot of fun and I just enjoy watching it most any day.
7. Lady and the Tramp- sweet, simple, romantic and with some tension and laughs. Just something so pleasant I can’t think of a time when I would not enjoy watching it. As the poster says the ‘happiest motion picture’ from early Disney.
8. 101 Dalmatians- A lot of of humor with Cruella, fun lively story, lots of great characters. Dry with with Horace and Jasper. Always at the top of my rewatch list.
9. Lilo and Stitch- Probably my most emotional film on this list but it is so lovingly told and Lilo is such a real kid I am drawn to the picture despite my dislike for Stitch. Maybe part of it is I find the Hawaiian local and music so relaxing it’s an easy rewatch for me.. It brings back many happy memories.
10. Mulan- Another movie with a lot of humor, romance, heart, and excitement. Just thoroughly entertaining and not too deep or morose like other less rewatchable films.
Honorable Mentions- Beauty and the Beast although it feels a little long for a frequent rewatch, Little Mermaid because of my nostalgia for it, and Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh which is probably the most rewatchable for little one’s.