I was planning on waiting till Christmas Eve to review the Muppet’s Christmas Carol because my family and I will often watch it on Christmas Eve. But I finished earlier than I expected and this is my last Scrooge review and we are ending with a real winner.
I am well aware that readers of this blog do not share my attachment to Muppet Christmas Carol and I respect their opinion but it has no effect on mine . I love this version and it battles Alistair Sims and George C Scott as my favorite.
Am I blinded by nostalgia? I don’t think so. I do love The Muppets. They are so cheerful it is hard for me to imagine people not liking them. To me it is like Looney Tunes, Winnie the Pooh or Mickey and Friends they are a part of my childhood but the writing and joy in the stories transcend childishness and become entertainment for all.
That said, I certainly do not give Muppets a free pass in all their films. The writing has to be there just like with any other artform or entertainment franchise. In fact, this year I included Muppets Most Wanted on my worst of the year list. The Great Muppet Caper is another less successful entry in the Muppet world.
The key to making a Muppets movie work (or most any film for families) is the human characters, the grownups, have to play it completely straight like they would if they were acting with any other human actors. When Steve Martin acts with Kermit and Miss Piggy in the original Muppet Movie he plays it just the same as he would if it was Chevy Chase and Jane Curtain.
Muppet Christmas Carol is the best example of playing it straight. Michael Caine does not change his performance an inch because he is acting with Muppets. I love his version of Scrooge.
When he yells at the bookkeepers or throws cute little Beaker and Bunson out as the Benefactors there is no acknowledgement of their cuteness. He is as Gonzo’s Dickens says ‘a covetous old sinner’.
Gonzo and Rizzo are our narrators and Gonzo is Dickens and so we get a ton of the actual text for a kids version, and the story plays pretty close to the cuff compared to other adaptations.
I think that’s great for kids to hear the old English and at the end they invite the children to read the book.
“Nice story Mr Dickens” says Rizzo
“Oh thanks. If you like this you should read the book” says Gonzo as Dickens
I love that!
They also provide much of the humor in the story to help temper the scarier moments for kids. Like when Gonzo lights Rizzo’s tail and he says ‘light the lamp, not the rat”. I don’t know a kid that wouldn’t laugh at that (and me too!).
I’m also a big fan of Muppet Treasure Island which cast a brilliant Tim Curry who can ham it up more as a pirate than Caine’s Scrooge but I think both are strong at teaching kids about a classic piece of English literature in an approachable and fun way.
Scrooge- As I already said I love Michael Caine as Scrooge. I think he is tough but I love how we actually see Scrooge cry and early on too. When he see’s his young self studying alone he cries. When he see’s Belle he is visibly hurt. He is one of the most vulnerable Scrooge’s on film and I love that!
When he see’s Tiny Tim he says ‘a remarkable child’ and it feels sincere even though it is a frog puppet. I actually feel it is one of the better Scrooge/Tim relationships.
See the warmth in Scrooge’s eyes and this is at the very beginning of his journey. Sometimes the transformation happens too late. We don’t see any growth or tenderness until the 3rd ghost. Not so in this version.
The songs do a great job telling the story instead of stopping it which many versions do incorrectly. Like our introduction to Scrooge tells us everything we need to know and provides a few laughs along the way. To me the song Scrooge is kind of like Belle from Beauty and the Beast. Both songs are a character going through town and people telling us who they are what the story is.
In contrast think of I Hate People in the Finney version tells us Scrooge hates people after we’ve already established that. The song is completely unnecessary; whereas, the one’s from Muppets tell the story.
Differences/Strengths-
Aside from the basic difference of being Muppets as the characters it does stay pretty close to the book.
The Paul Williams songs and Miles Goodman score are just lovely. I have them on my rotation of Christmas Carols and definitely think they are the best Christmas Carol musical efforts.
Instead of just Bob Cratchit there are rats that are bookkeepers and they provide one great joke and help Kermit close up for Christmas with my favorite song of the film:
It’s such a warm and happy song. Really spells Christmas out for me.
Another difference is instead of one Marley they have 2 brothers- Jacob and Robert Marley. This is so the curmudgeons Statler and Waldorf could play them and it is all done very well. I love the way they mock Scrooge, taunt and heckle him. That’s so S and W and feels like something 2 Marley’s might have done.
Again Caine plays the scene as if he was working with any human actors and it works very well. I love the singing cashboxes!
They take us to see Scrooge growing up and we get a good joke from Sam the Eagle.
But we don’t get a Scrooge and Fan scene which is a shame because I think Caine would have been great with that. Then we move on to Mr Fozziwigs who is of course Fozzie and they work in a lot of the other characters in the party scene.
We then finish off Past with Belle and Scrooge. Present is one of my favorites with a unique Muppet who is one of the few Presents to actually age. He and Scrooge have a real bond.
It feels genuine when Caine says “I have learned so much from you. You have meant so much to me. You have changed me” I love that example of friendship. So many versions the townspeople and even Present can be kind of judgy and mean but here they were all aching to be friends with Scrooge.
We get another great song from Present.
And the interactions at Fred’s and at Cratchit’s feel like real families, not silly puppets.
I love that the girls are pigs and the boys are frogs. That was very clever.
Tim sings a syrupy but nice Christmas song for the God Bless Everyone line and again Scrooge seems very moved by it.
Rizzo is also very funny in these scenes with some good slapstick.
We then get a pretty classic Future. I really liked how they did the Pawn Shop scene with Old Joe as a spider. That was very creative.
The other businessmen were pigs which I thought was a funny inside joke and then we see the Cratchit’s mourning over Tim and again Scrooge seems very upset by it.
He pleads with Future “Oh spirit must there be a Christmas that brings this awful scene. How can we endure it”. That’s a lovely heartfelt moment. Makes me tear up.
Rizzo and Gonzo (Dickens) bow out for ending which helps it remain the serious tone it should.
It is one of my favorite if a bit subtle Crazy Scrooge. The Bean Bunny Scrooge throws out for singing is the boy in the window which is sweet because when he is at Present you see him shivering huddled with newspaper.
Then he meets up with Beaker and Bunson and Beaker gives Scrooge his first Christmas present a scarf and we get our final song. A lot of people are critical of Caine’s singing in this song but I don’t know I think he’s fine.
Weaknesses- Honestly I love this movie so I don’t think much is wrong with it. I really don’t. I guess if people want a by the book version than the humor might annoy you but I like it.
Some of the special effects are lame when Scrooge is going from one world to another or flying.
To me this does what you want a family movie to do. It is warm, funny, sweet, good songs and a few scares. Plus, it introduces kids to classic literature by using lots of the text and being pretty faithful to the narrative. It doesn’t dumb it down for kids.
I guess people that just don’t like the Muppets even at their best don’t like it but I try to be open minded to all styles and forms of movies. I know people who just don’t like anime no matter how brilliant and creative it might be and I think that’s a shame.
If the humor and style doesn’t work for you than so be it but I love it.
I was wondering when you were going to review this one!
I can’t remember exactly, but this was probably my first exposure to the story of A Christmas Carol. I watched it again just the other day, and like with Beauty and the Beast, it’s great how much more you can appreciate watching it as an adult.
You’re right about Michael Caine: his Scrooge is fantastic and the fact that he’s acting alongside Muppets doesn’t make any difference in that. I like how when he’s in his office, he gradually gets openly angry about having Christmas forced on him, to the point of tearing down Fred’s wreath and the way he growls “What do you want?” at the carol singer; and I like seeing how he changes and shows more vulnerability, even if maybe it happens a little too quickly in the Present sequence. The Muppets themselves fill their roles very well, particularly Kermit as Bob Cratchit. This film’s versions of the three spirits are still probably my favourites, though maybe that’s just because I’m most familiar with them – but even so, Christmas Present is very jolly and likeable and the design on Christmas Yet To Come looks more ominous and scary than others I’ve seen. (“And this is supposed to be a kid’s movie!” as Rizzo might put it.)
And the songs are great too – though most times when I’ve seen this film on TV, “The Love is Gone” gets edited out. It just goes straight from Belle saying “You did once” to her walking away and Rizzo crying.
So yes, it deserves just as much respect as any other adaptation.
Couldn’t have said it better myself! I agree on all your points. Jeffrey Katzenberg is responsible for taking out Love is Gone because he thought it was too sad. I kind of agree. I don’t hate the song but it is long and kind of slows the momentum.
It’s pretty amazing when you think Michael Caine was on platforms most of the time with puppeters beneath him. You would never tell. Tina Fey is much less successful pulling that off in this years Muppets movie
I agree with you on the spirits. They are very well done and I like that Scrooge develops a real relationship with all 3. That again says something about Caine’s performance.
I’m glad you enjoy it! Merry Christmas.
I first saw ‘The Muppet Christmas Carol’ on VHS, and it included the “Love is Gone” song, which I still contend was a vital part of the film because it shows us the heartbreak that Scrooge experienced as a young man and brings out the emotions perfectly. I hated that the DVD cut that scene out, because it looks like a very awkward jump from a slightly sad scene between Scrooge and Belle to Rizzo crying his eyes out, and there’s nothing to provide context to that scene. I have no plans to buy the blu-ray or any future releases until Disney release a complete version with the “Love is Gone” song included.
Apart from that bit of controversy, this is still one of my favourite Muppet movies and a great film even without the rose tinted glasses. Merry Christmas. 🙂
On the bluray you can watch both versions.
That’s interesting, I’ll be sure to look deeper into it. Cheers! 🙂
Merry Christmas! I can see why you love that scene. It definitely has the feels. Just not my favorite song but nice they offer it both ways. Wish George Lucas would do that
You said it! At least, other directors like Peter Jackson, James Cameron and Ridley Scott give their fans the element of choice when it comes to which version of their movies their fans can see!
I know this is very old, but you can watch both versions on the DVD too. Just choose full screen instead of widescreen.
This was a great version, both for kids and their parents. My only problem with it was how the Marley role was split between Statler and Waldorf. They weren’t scary, and they weren’t funny either. It just seemed like an excuse for the writers to fit in all the death jokes they could. In my opinion, S and W would be better off as the businessmen discussing Scrooge’s death in the Christmas Future segment. W: I don’t know anyone who’d go to his funeral! S: Well, I might go. W: You will? S: If there’s a lunch provided! Both: Dohohoho!
Who would you had as Marley?
I just re-watched the film again on the DVD I got from my grandmother for Christmas when I was about 9. It’s annoyingly pan-and-scanned, but the film still holds up well and it does include the original song between Scrooge and his former lover that was cut out of the theatrical release.
Granted I haven’t read the original story (despite Gonzo/Dickens’ recommendation), but it really is a very solid retelling. What’s strange is it almost feels like two different movies, with the Muppet hijinks taking place in one while in the other Scrooge’s story is told with dead seriousness. And I completely agree with you about Michael Caine’s performance. The thing I love about this film is how he never once acts as if he is aware that he is in a Muppet version of the classic story. So much so that if you just played his scenes as Scrooge to someone, they would probably be shocked to learn that it wasn’t from a straightforward adaptation. Michael Caine’s rendition of Scrooge can certainly compete with any of the greats, from Alastair Sim to George C. Scott to Albert Finney, and so forth. The fact that the writing only services that all the better is just the cream on the cake.
I only have two complaints: the first being that the Muppet comedy feels incredibly forced and out of place. If you pay attention, virtually none of it comes out of the actual plot, making you wonder why it needed to be a Muppet version at all. The only thing it does add is an interesting metafictional commentary on the story, which in itself is probably enough for me to recommend it, as it gives an amusing and intriguing level of self-awareness to the story that we never get by just watching it play out.
I also think the flashback scenes are a bit disappointing. What we do learn about Scrooge’s childhood is interesting, and helps explain why he became the “squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous, old sinner” that he is introduced to us as. It just never seems to do enough. What we do see does wonders to help humanize Scrooge, combined with Caine’s refreshingly sympathetic and human portrayal, but it never seems to go far enough somehow. Just when we start to really understand him, the film simply moves away, and creates more psychic distance.
But these are mostly small quibbles. It’s easy to see why Charles Dickens’ own grandson referred to this as one of the best adaptations of A Christmas Carol. But really, I think the greatest accomplishment of the film is that it kept the Muppets’ legacy alive and well in the wake of Jim Henson’s death and is something it feels obvious he would have been proud of. His vision of the Muppets and their timeless innocence rings true from beginning to end, and that’s what anchors things.
Nice review. Thanks for sharing. I think they needed the humor to make the story appeal to kids or at least that’s probably what they were thinking. I don’t mind it personally
What is pan-and-scan?
YouTube video